A Study in Fic: The World’s Most Random Rec Post
Hello, dear followers. First of all, we want to thank everyone who sent us supportive messages after we went on hiatus. We’d especially like to thank those of you who promptly exploded angst-clouds of despair all over our dash and inbox. Your tears were delicious
It’s so wonderful to know that y’all miss us when we’re gone.
As some of you may remember, about four score and seven years ago, we promised you a list of the fic submitted during our fandom-wide scavenger hunt, A Study in Fic.
Seeing as those submissions numbered somewhere in the low hundreds (and we didn’t ask for quality), we figured it would be best if we vetted them a bit first. So here, for your reading pleasure, is the Study in Fic Rec List.

Round 1
Sherlock is royalty:
- The Engagement
- Pumpkin King (Art)
Zombies:
- A Brief Account of Life With Zombies
- Immunity
- A London Blitz
- The Plan
- You, After the Rain
John is some kind of animal:
- Being Sherlock (Werewolf)
- The Doctor is Out (Kinda sorta dog)
- Gone is My Past (Dog)
- The Lobster Quadrille (Lobster)
- Murderous, Co-Dependent (Kitten)
- My Body When It Is With Your (Werewolf)
- Alien (Art)(Cat)
- The Great Mouse Sherlock (Art)(Mouse)
- John is made of kittens (Art)(Kittens. Duh)
- My Little Pony (Art)(Pony)
- On The Day (Art)(Hedgehog)
Body parts in [insert appliance here]:
- Disguise
- House Rules
- (Let You Kiss Me (So Sweet and So Soft)
- The Progress of Sherlock Holmes
- Meeting the Family
- Shadows On the Wall
- The Shape I Found You In
- A Slowly Dawning Attraction
- Woe and Arachnids
- Entrails in the Tub (Art)
Fic in which line from show is directly quoted:
- Art of the Reasoner
- Bound In Gold
- Identification
- Learning Curve
- Pedestrian
- Pleasure Dome Hotel
- The Right Question
- A Study in Sexuality
- The(y) Kiss
- But It’s the Solar System (Art)
And, Making the Connection Be sure to read this one! Both Scarf and I really wanted to rec it. Unfortunately, it was still a WIP when our hiatus started.
Round 2
Either John or Sherlock gets/has a tattoo:
- The Curious Case of the Talking Tattoo
- The Road Less Traveled (Christmas special)
- The Tattoo
- The Army Dcotor (Art)
- Unnamed (Art)
- Welp (Art)
The Vest Explodes:
- Apotheosis
- Guns and Rubble
- The Heart in the Whole
- I Prefer to Text
- Dive (Art)
Abandoned WIP that never should have died:
- Catastrophic Mechanical Failure (Scarf: Best thing ever in the world. John gets injured in the Funvee with Tony Stark.
Excuse my obvious Tony feels)
- Elementary, My Dear Watson
- Matchmaker, Matchmaker
- Sherlock is a Professional Matchmaker
- A Study in Squirrels
Superpowers (someone has them):
- Blood From a Stone
- An Experiment in Empathy
- Facing the Odds
- It Only Takes a Spark
- John is Blessed With Suck
- The Queen’s Guard
- Reader
- A Spell of Deduction
- They Tell Me Their Secrets (Will You Tell Me Yours Too?)
- Threshold
John/jam = OTP:
- In Which Sherlock Has More Friends Than He Knows What To Do With
- Need Jam To Live (Art)
Round 3
Sports AU:
- Road Swing
- A Study in Winning
Deus ex Mycroft:
- Backup Copies
- Deus ex Mycroft
- Infiltrate
- I Used to Live Alone Before I Knew You
- Lemsip
- Proportionate Response
- The Theory of Narrative Causality
- To Be Needed
- Traffic Lights for the Colour Blind
- A Very Important Experiment
In which one of the boys stitches the other up:
- The Good Doctor
- Stitches
- Googling How to Suture a Wound (Art)
John in a bee costume:
- Halloween (Art)
Moriarty does some good (intentionally or not):
- The Anatomist
- Da Steht Auch Ein Mensch
- Please Jim Will You Fix It?
Round 4
John speaking a Middle Eastern language:
- Come and See
- Two Two One Bravo Baker
- Upon This Charge
- Ya’aburnee
BAMF!Mrs. Hudson:
- It’s Not The Violin
- Shortfill!
- Tea and Concussions
- You Took My Hand And Danced With Me
- Mrs. Hudson + Shotgun (Art)
Daddy Holmes:
- So Easy For Everybody Else
- Winter’s Delights
- Sherlock’s First Christmas (Art)
Sherlock is secretly interested in or obsessed with [insert pop reference here]:
- Monster
- Senza Catene
- Angry Birds (Art)
- Rocky Horror (Art)
Asexual John:
- Asexual!John Fill
- Surprisingly Simple
Now that we’ve served our purpose by killing all productive urges, we must bid you all a fond farewell.
Adieu, old fellows, with a cordial handshake. Yours sincerely, Jumper and Scarf.